Michael is upset with everyone comparing him to John and is even more upset when Peter asks him to wait for John before they fly off to Neverland. While everyone is playing in the amusement park in Neverland, Michael who is once again challenged by John, walks off sulking. He decides to follow Smee and Jake when he hears them talking about a temple. Soon, the three of them get trapped inside the Aztec looking temple. Wendy is worried about Michael while Peter insists that its always the pirates who are to blame when something goes wrong in Neverland. Soon, the pirates, Peter, Wendy and the Lost Kids go in search of Michael and the pirates. Hook goes mostly because he wants to find the golden temple. Michael, Smee and Jake soon find a way out of the temple only to discover a battle raging outside the temple. Michael is soon captured by the pirates and it is upto Peter to save him from the devious Captain Hook who wants Peter in return for Michael. Peter now has a tough choice to make. Will he give himself up or will he manage to save himself and Michael?