Wendy, like other young girls, cant seem to decide between buying a cute top or a handbag. Meanwhile in Neverland, Hook and his pirates are huffing and puffing and chasing Peter Pan. Peter taunts them saying how sad it is for them to be old whilst he will forever be a boy. He drops the hat on the captain's head and takes off laughing. Hook and Smee realize that if Peter aged a bit, they could catch him easily and they start hatching a devious plan. Peter and the Lost Kids stay on the island because they are children. But if they become grownups, they'll have to leave. They decide the only way this can happen is if Peter had to make a grown up decision. When the pirates kidnap Wendy and Tinkerbell, it is upto Peter to save them. But he has to make a choice- Wendy or Tinkerbell! Peter soon comes up with a plan where he saves one of his friends while the mermaids save the other. Does Peter save both his friends?